Rank

C

1B

2B

3B

SS

LF

CF

RF

P

1

Josh Gibson

Lou Gehrig

Rogers Hornsby

George Scales

Willie Wells

Al Simmons

Turkey Stearnes

Babe Ruth

Lefty Grove

2

Bill Dickey

Buck Leonard

Charlie Gehringer

John Beckwith

Arky Vaughan

Goose Goslin

Oscar Charleston

Mel Ott

Bill Foster

3

Biz Mackey

Jimmie Foxx

Frankie Frisch

Stan Hack

Lou Boudreau

Joe Medwick

Joe DiMaggio

Ted Strong

Satchel Paige

4

Mickey Cochrane

Mule Suttles

Newt Allen

Judy Johson

Luke Appling

Bob Johnson

Willard Brown

Paul Waner

Ray Brown

5

Gabby Hartnett

Johnny Mize

Billy Herman

Dobie Moore

Ken Williams

Cristóbal Torriente

Harry Heilmann

Stan Coveleski

6

Wally Schang

Jud Wilson

Lonny Frey

Joe Cronin

Augie Galan

Bullet Rogan

Chuck Klein

Bullet Rogan

7

Hank Greenberg

John Henry Lloyd

Martin Dihigo

Heinie Manush

Cool Papa Bell

Hurley McNair

Hal Newhouser

8

Bill Terry

Dick Lundy

Jeff Heath

Max Carey

Roy Cullenbine

Bob Feller

9

George Sisler

Travis Jackson

Hack Wilson

Ed Stone

Bill Byrd

10

Dolph Camilli

Dave Bancroft

Wally Berger

Branch Russell

Carl Hubbell

11

Edgar Wesley

Sam Bankhead

Earl Averill

William Bell

12

Rabbit Maranville

Earle Combs

Dazzy Vance

13

Edd Roush

Hilton Smith

14

Alejandro Oms

Ted Lyons

15

Lefty Gomez