Splits Post Season

About Musings Q & A *Contact me*

Hitting a HOMA!

Baseball's Live Ball Era "Hall of Maximum Achievement"

Roberto Clemente

Fine Tuning Achievement

The Secret Sauce 2.0 PED Users

The original version of the Hall of Maximum Achievement (HOMA) relied on Peak WAR and career OPS+/ERA+ for its basis. To be truer to its name, this 2.0 HOMA version emphasizes only peak measures that are in relation to the entire group of major league players (i.e. not just replacement level).This updated version uses Peak WAA (Wins Above Average) and the combo stat Peak OPS+ and Peak Rdef+ (named Peak O&D) for position players and Peak WAA and Peak ERA+ for pitchers, with some adjustment for modern day relief pitcher appearances.

The various peak scores are finally scaled and weighted (70-30 Peak WAA to Peak O&D for position players and a 2 to 1 ratio Peak WAA to Peak ERA+ for pitchers) to come up with a final HOMA score.

An additional HOMA-C score takes account of championship series play. Final scores of 99 or greater quality players for induction into either the Hall Of Maximum Achievement or its related championship version, HOMA-C.

All Major Leagues?

Includes player performance from the 7 Negro Leagues (1920-1948) now recognized as Major Leagues.

Who Hit a HOMA?

Top 60 Position Players

(Mouse pointer hover (laptop) or tap image (phone) to view key stats/HOMA scores)

(All category scores normed to 100 as the HOMA cutoff)

(As of 6-22-24)


Babe Ruth
Willie Mays
(1) RF-1
(2) CF-1
Barry Bonds
Rogers Hornsby
(3) LF-1
(4) 2B-1
Hank Aaron
Ted Williams
(5) RF-2
(6) LF-2
Josh Gibson
Turkey Stearnes
(7) C-1
(8) CF-2
Lou Gehrig
Stan Musial
(9) 1B-1
(10) 1B-2
Mickey Mantle
Oscar Charleston
(11) CF-3
(12) CF-4
Mike Schmidt
Willie Wells
(13) 3B-1
(14) SS-1
Mel Ott
Rickey Henderson
(15) RF-3
(16) LF-3
Albert Pujols
Buck Leonard
(17) 1B-3
(18) 1B-4
Frank Robinson
Alex Rodriguez
(19) RF-4
(20) SS-2
Jimmie Foxx
Wade Boggs
(21) 1B-5
(22) 3B-2
Roberto Clemente
Eddie Mathews
(23) RF-5
(24) 3B-3
Joe Morgan
George Brett
(25) 2B-2
(26) 3B-4
Willard Brown
Joe DiMaggio
(27) CF-5
(28) CF-6
Mule Suttles
Al Kaline
(29) 1B-6
(30) RF-6
Carl Yastrzemski
Ken Griffey Jr
(31) LF-4
(32) CF-7
Cal Ripken
Jeff Bagwell
(33) SS-3
(34) 1B-7
Jud Wilson
Arky Vaughan
(35) 3B-5
(36) SS-4
Adrian Beltre
Chipper Jones
(37) 3B-6
(38) 3B-7
Charlie Gehringer
Johnny Mize
(39) 2B-3
(40) 1B-8
Larry Doby
George Scales
(41) CF-8
(42) 3B-8
Larry Walker
Rod Carew
(43) RF-7
(44) 1B-9
Jackie Robinson
Reggie Jackson
(45) 2B-4
(46) RF-8
Johnny Bench
Ron Santo
(47) C-2
(48) 3B-9
Chase Utley
Scott Rolen
(49) 2B-5
(50) 3B-10
Barry Larkin
Frank Thomas
(51) SS-5
(52) DH-1
Lou Boudreau
Gary Carter
(53) SS-6
(54) C-3
Ted Strong
Edgar Martinez
(55) RF-9
(56) DH-2
Miguel Cabrera
Paul Waner
(57) 1B-10
(58) RF-10
Alan Trammell
Robin Yount
(59) SS-7
(60) SS-8

View more HOMA Position Players?


Top 40 Pitchers

(As of 6-22-24)

Lefty Grove
Roger Clemens
(1)
(2)
Satchel Paige
Bill Foster
(3)
(4)
Randy Johnson
(5)
Pedro Martinez
Greg Maddux
(6)
(7)
Ray Brown
Bill Byrd
(8)
(9)
Tom Seaver
Curt Schilling
(10)
(11)
Bob Gibson
Bert Blyleven
(12)
(13)
Bullet Rogan
Roy Halladay
(14)
(15)
Mike Messina
(16)
William Bell
Gaylord Perry
(17)
(18)
Phil Niekro
Hilton Smith
(19)
(20)
Steve Carlton
Stan Coveleski
(21)
(22)
Hal Newhouser
John Smoltz
(23)
(24)
Eugene Bremer
Bob Feller
(25)
(26)
Mariano Rivera
(27)
David Cone
Carl Hubbell
(28)
(29)
Johan Santana
Warren Spahn
(30)
(31)
Robin Roberts
Tom Glavine
(32)
(33)
Jim Palmer
Dave Brown
(34)
(35)
Dazzy Vance
Dennis Eckersley
(36)
(37)
Roy Oswalt
Kevin Brown
(38)
(39)
Bill Holland
(40)

View more HOMA Pitchers?

Rev 2.0 HOMA Candidates Scores Table


Above table divided into text files:

Retired: Position Players Pitchers


Rankings by Position

C 1B 2B 3B SS LF CF RF DH SP RP


Negro Leagues

NGL Position Players NGL Pitchers

Eras

HOMA Position Rankings: Discriminated Integrated


Relation to HOF

HOFers HOF But Not HOMA HOMA But Not HOF

Return to Top

Hittin' A HOMA has been brought to you by Don Sobocinski- a lover of the game and an occasional, very limited, software maven. Much thanks to Baseball-Reference for their incredible work that is the basis for the site's statistics. As for this place, thanks for stopping by! And feel free to use after you peruse.